Does anybody even care about ‘live’ albums anymore? Does anybody
these days have the attention span to sit down for an evening and
immerse themselves in a concert experience simulation situation? I
suppose the question is, does anybody have the attention span to sit
down and just listen to an entire album,Period!? Well this post is
assuming that there are those sorts of people left on earth.
In the past, live albums usually were produced for two reasons. That
is, to fill in the gap while waiting for the next studio album. Or as a
career or specific period overview of the ‘Best Of’ but presented in the
novel ‘live album’ form. Sort of to remind everybody of their greatest
hits and because of the crowd noises, remind everybody how famous they
were(or still are).
But how ‘artistically’ important are these albums? Are they actually
necessary? Some bands approach the stage with the idea that they must
perform the songs just like they appear on the record, otherwise certain
fans will think they’re no good live because it doesn’t sound like the
album. “Unless you play that solo note for note just like the record,
I’ll think that you suck ‘live’”. For example-Supertramp-PARIS. I enjoy
listening to that album, but is it essential listening? Is it a stand
alone Supertramp album or is it just a greatest hits package with crowd
noises? I enjoy Pink Floyd-PULSE and also DELICATE SOUND OF THUNDER, but
they’re so close to the album versions that I consider them to be
career retrospectives rather than a unique individual album.
Am I wrong to think this? Well, I’m writing the bloody article here and you’re not!
My personal preference is to think that live and studio are two
different mediums and should be approached as such. I don’t think that a
group that can reproduce the sound of their album on stage is
accomplishing a really great thing(having to use recorded stuff and
click tracks). I think that a group should hit the stage with just their
instruments and GO! And if they play well and are also good
entertainers, an audience shouldn’t feel cheated because it’s not like
the record! In fact they should go home having been thoroughly
entertained and satisfied.
So,,,The live albums I tend to recommend to people (who are remotely
interested) are the ones that are NOT like the original record but are
albums that can be considered an integral part of an artist’s catalog.
An album that doesn’t sound just like a retrospective, but is a
completely different album from anything else they have.
Here are six albums that I absolutely adore. Albums that capture an
event(or a few events edited together into an entertaining collection).
There are many more that I will have missed but these ones I’ve
arbitrarily chosen for this post!
Walang komento:
Mag-post ng isang Komento